Inflation, Monetary policy and India

 The minutes of the recent meeting of Monetary Policy Committee  of RBi which were released this week, contain some interesting mentions. One of the news columns said that RBI minutes mention 'uncertainty' 12 times, 'growth' 43 times and 'inflation' 147 times It has expressed concern over inflation and it seems to be valid as CPI has remained above 6% which is more than the tolerance limit of RBI. Alongside, India is experiencing severe GDP growth pangs as its IIP has remained in the negative territory in the first quarter and in July also. Services sector is in a deeper mess except of course ITES, SAAS etc. which have been affected to a lesser extent. It looks like only Agri sector has not been impacted adversely so far ,as the progress of monsoon has been satisfactory and the spatial dispersion also fairly good.

The RBI Deputy Governor Mr.Michael Patra had said : "If inflation persists above the upper tolerance band for one more quarter, monetary policy will be constrained by the mandate to undertake remedial action, including an immediate and more than a proportionate response to head off the build-up of inflation pressures and prevent it from getting generalized." So, to sum it up ,we have classic case of "stagflation"- a combo of GDP slowdown and inflation.!

CPI in India has a higher weightage for food and fuel indices and these two are certainly not amenable to monetary policy measures. In India fuel price is driven more by Govt . policy measures and it is feeding into inflation with its rippling effects on the rest of the economy widespread.When pandemic is restricting economic activities profiteering becomes rampant in vegetable and food prices. When the supply chain and free movement of people and commodities happen, the inflation tendencies will come down. Cost push inflation of food prices will not listen to monetary policy signals in the short term in Indian conditions. As India is driven more by cash , there is a quite a lag in food inflation responding to monetary policy measures, if at all it is significant. May be hoarding and black marketing of these vegetables,cereals ,staples etc. may come down a little bit.However Govt. initiatives through Essential commodities and anti-hoarding sticks used by Govt. through other means incl. emergency imports may be more effective in the short term to bring down food prices.

When the economy is awash with liquidity, the prices in general have tendencies to go north .More so when the supply constraints remain elevated due to lockdowns,e-passes and uncertainties compounded by fear for life and livelihood affecting the income. In these circumstances. RBI should look at high CPI as extraordinary during the pandemic period and should start looking at Core inflation now and then revert back to CPI only after the pandemic is seen plateauing.In the meantime, RBI may seek a temporary amendment for its inflation targeting, switching to Core inflation in times of extraordinary circumstances like a pandemic,global financial crises etc. and then have a glide path back to CPI inflation targeting after the crest of the crises is over.

RBI monetary policy and the state of the Indian economy

 RBI's recent Monetary Policy announcement after MPC considered the latest economic factors, CPI etc , came out with no repo rate cut. Primarily because CPI is elevated and at an uncomfortable level as far as RBI is concerned.since the mandated and stated objective of RBI is now inflation control, RBI has decided to hold the rate this time despite the economic slowdown calling for a steep rate cut.RBI also mentioned that this year would see real GDP contraction after more than four decades, but still decided to save the powder for a more rainy day or for a day when the bang will be worth its buck.

India is facing rising prices also esp. food prices, fuel prices and therefore is experiencing a cost push inflation. There is a school of economists who say the inflation is fueled by easy liquidity floating in the economy and the stock exchange boom , gold price rise all indicate to easy money into areas where some quick money can be made.Even RBI is predicting a rise in inflation levels in Q2 but has refrained from an inflation forecast.

Gold price,as Ruchir Sharma in today's TOI blog(link )puts it, rises due to uptick in demand whenever interest rate is lower than the inflation rate. But Gold being a safe haven investment booms when the rest of the economy sees more volatility elsewhere esp. in stable investments. There is a rush of outflow from equity MFs in July but is it going to Debt MFs or to stock market or to gold  is anybody's guess.But there is greater desperation driving up buying Gold rather than preference as an investment.

All this paint a confusing story but with tinges of liquidity bulge which may become an inflation down the road, unless the productive resources are used for assets and jobs creation. But the silverlinings are shallow oil prices, decent monsoon, burgeoning foreign exchange reserves and surplus in current account balance. So, cost push factors in inflation are slightly mitigated in the near to short term.

CII 's recent 111th Business Outlook survey,July 2020, which was released last month revealed that out of three indeces Current situation index, Expectation index, Business confidence index, the Current Situation Index of Q1 of Fy 20-21 is similar to the levels of Q4 of Fy 19-20! Only the Expectations and Business Confidence levels in the economy have deteriorated during Q1 of Fy 20-21 as compared to earlier quarter.

Dr.Manmohan Singh in his BBC interview has also clearly said that this human crisis created by the pandemic calls for greater spending and greater borrowings by the GOI, even upto another 10% of GDP for tackling health, military and economic challenges of the country. His wise words would be worthy of listening now.(link)

But this borrowing must have a clear exit clause linking it to FRBM Act requirement of glided fiscal deficit path to 3% of GDP eventually in the short to medium term of 3/4 years. Only this can bring back investors into the country. Otherwise Fiscal profligacy is the scourge of the growing economies like India.

There are no simple answers but quick actions,as outlined by PM in his speech on the occasion of  Ram janmasthan Temple laying foundation,have to be taken by the Govt. Quoting from Kamba Ramayana he said "காலம் தாழ ஈண்டு இனும் இருத்தி போலாம்" என்றான் இராமன்" which essentially means we should not procrastinate taking actions to rectify the situation. A well focused fiscal stimulus, vaccine or no vaccine, is an urgent imperative.

Reforms in Power sector.

Central Govt announced Rs.90K cr rescue package for power gencos through PFC and REC.But PRAAPTI ( Payment Ratification And Analysis in Power procurement for bringing Transparency in Invoicing of generators) website shows that the total overdue amount to be paid to Gencos stood at Rs.113.8K cr at the end of May 2020 continuously going up for the last 18 to 24 months. The total outstandings were Rs.125.6K cr.link.

Apart from this, there is renewable energy generation pending to be adjusted against captive consumption of factories which is not yet visible.This may be another iceberg submerged.

After clearing Rs.90K cr.as per GOI plan  stated above, how the state discoms are going to manage their future liabilities.

With a negative gap between Average Cost of Supply(ACS) and Average Revenue Realised at Re.0.41 per unit on an All India basis, it is a losing game. AT & C loss is also still very high at 18.72%link.UDAY (Ujwal Discom Assurance Yojana) commitments lie in tatters.

All the UDAY Targets remain unfulfilled. The website says there are no newsletter releases after Jan 2019 and that sums up the state of affairs under UDAY. UDAY is now Asthamana.It looks like an orphan.

Targets on All India basis set were:

Feeder Metering                                   30th June 2016 
DT Metering                                          30th June 2017
AT&C Losses                                        15% by FY 2019
Consumer Indexing & GIS Mapping      30th Sep 2018
Upgradation of DT,Meters etc.              31st Dec 2017
Smart meter for Consumers                >500 units by Dec 2017;>200 units by Dec 2019
Elimination of ACS-ARR gap                 FY 2019

Smart metering completion is at 6% - 7%  on All India basis as per the website UDAY.in whereas , it should have been completed  100% by Dec 2019 according to the Targets set.

Are there methods amidst madness to come out of this mess?. There are practical methods to bring down AT &C loss by upgrading the cable quality.adoption of smart metering etc. But the easiest way to do is by horizontal deployment across states. State of Himachal Pradesh has the lowest AT &C at 5.62%. There are great lessons for other states to learn from them. The lowest gap between ACS and ARR is in Gujarat at just 4 paise. This will open the eyes of other States.This cross fertilisation of ideas is the way forward to healthy federal competition.

Many political parties give electoral promises of free electricity to farmers to win elections and in the guise of farmers many use free electricity even for their farm houses. This misuse is rampant across India.

The best way to counter this is to transfer subsidy given to marginal farmers to their Jan dhan account and charge uniformly for agri sector. Another method could be charge 10 paise for a unit for agri activity instead of calling it free and increase this tariff every year by indexing it to CPInflation for those agriculturists consuming more than 1000 units per annum.