Some factors negatively impacting India's GDP growth
Forecasting private consumption in India until March 2025 requires careful consideration of several factors.:
Positive Factors:
- Rural Demand Strength: Rural consumption shows signs of revival, boosted by a healthy kharif harvest and increased FMCG sales, along with three-wheeler and tractor sales. This suggests strong rural income and spending.
- Festive Season: The upcoming festive season is expected to positively impact urban consumer demand.
- Government Spending: Increased government spending is anticipated to boost investment activity.
- Stable External Sector: A stable external sector provides further support to economic growth.
Negative Factors:
- Moderation in Urban Demand: Urban demand shows signs of moderation as per Finance Ministry, with softening consumer sentiment and limited footfall. This is a significant concern, as urban consumption constitutes a larger portion of the overall economy.
- Inflation: While inflation appears well-contained, barring a few vegetable prices, any unexpected price spikes could negatively affect consumer spending.
- Geopolitical and Geoeconomic Uncertainty: Global uncertainties could negatively impact household sentiments and spending.
- AI-Driven Job Displacement: Early signs of AI displacing workers could negatively impact employment and consumer confidence.
- Softening Manufacturing Momentum: The manufacturing PMI decline suggests slowing momentum in this key sector.
Forecast Considerations:
A precise forecast is impossible without more detailed data (like specific consumption figures, income data, detailed inflation forecasts, etc.). However, considering the above, a reasonable forecast would likely show:
- Moderate Growth: Given the conflicting signals, private consumption growth until March 2025 will probably be moderate, likely lower than previous years. The strength of rural demand will partially offset the weakness in urban areas.
- Potential for Disappointment: The reliance on the festive season to boost urban consumption carries some risk. If this fails to materialize significantly, overall private consumption could underperform expectations.
- Inflation as a Key Variable: Inflation's behavior will be crucial. If inflation remains controlled, the forecast is more likely to be positive. However, significant price increases could dampen consumer spending.
The CRISIL data highlights paint a picture of slowing industrial growth in India during August 2024, which would necessitate a downward revision of any existing economic forecast. Several key points need to be incorporated:
Contracting IIP: The Index of Industrial Production (IIP) contracted, signaling overall industrial slowdown. This directly impacts GDP growth projections.
Weakness Across Sectors: The contraction wasn't limited to one sector; it was broad-based, affecting primary goods (mining and electricity heavily impacted), capital goods (investment-related), infrastructure and construction, and intermediate goods. Consumer non-durables also showed very weak growth. This widespread weakness suggests a more significant economic slowdown than a sectoral issue.
Export Slowdown: The decline in merchandise exports further dampens the growth outlook. Reduced export demand often indicates weakening global economic conditions, potentially affecting India's economy further.
Consumption Weakness: The continued contraction in consumer non-durables for the third consecutive month is alarming. This suggests weakening consumer confidence and spending power, factors that would normally be expected to be more robust. This is a serious concern given this is the third consecutive month of declines.
To update the forecast:
To incorporate this information effectively, an updated economic forecast needs to:
Lower GDP Growth Projections: The broad-based industrial slowdown necessitates a reduction in projected GDP growth for the relevant quarter and the remainder of the fiscal year. The magnitude of the reduction will depend on the weight of the affected sectors in the overall economy and how much of that weakness persists.
Adjust Sectoral Forecasts: Specific growth rates for various sectors (mining, manufacturing, construction, etc.) should be revised downward to reflect the CRISIL data.
Consider Consumer Spending: Given the persistent weakness in consumer non-durable goods, the forecast should adjust for dampened consumer spending.
Assess External Factors: The export slowdown should be considered within a broader global economic context to determine the extent of its impact on India's economy.
Factor in Uncertainty: The data points to uncertainty in the Indian economy. The forecast should include a wider range of possible outcomes to reflect this uncertainty.
In short: The CRISIL data indicates a more pessimistic outlook than previously anticipated. A revised forecast must reflect this slowdown across multiple sectors and the weakness in both investment and consumption. The degree of the negative adjustment will require further economic data and analysis, but a reduction in growth projections is certain based on this information.
Based on the September 2024 Monthly Economic Review, India's economic forecast and private consumption outlook until March 2025 (FY25) present a mixed picture:
Economic Forecast:
Optimistic Aspects: The review underscores a healthy kharif harvest, robust services sector performance, and continued strength in rural demand fueled by good monsoons and government initiatives. The external sector also remains stable, with rising capital inflows and comfortable forex reserves. Manufacturing shows some softening but remains in expansionary territory according to several indicators.
Concerns: Urban demand displays moderation due to softening consumer sentiments, limited footfall (potentially due to weather), and seasonal purchasing patterns. While inflation is currently well-contained, the erratic monsoon impacted agricultural supplies, leading to a temporary rise in food inflation in September. Geopolitical uncertainties and potential global economic slowdowns pose risks.
Private Consumption Forecast:
Rural Consumption: Remains strong due to healthy agricultural output, government support, and increased FMCG sales. This sector is expected to continue its positive trajectory.
Urban Consumption: The outlook for urban consumption is more uncertain. While festive season spending is expected to provide a boost, the underlying trend shows moderation due to softening consumer sentiment and limited footfall. This sector's performance will be crucial in determining overall consumption growth.
Overall Consumption: A moderate growth in overall private consumption is likely until March 2025, with rural demand offsetting the weakness in urban areas. However, the extent of urban weakness and the success of the expected festive season boost will significantly impact the final figures. The uncertainty surrounding the external environment adds to this uncertainty.
Overall Economic Forecast:
The report anticipates an economic growth rate between 6.5% and 7.0% for FY25. This forecast reflects a balance between the positive aspects mentioned earlier (rural demand, stable external sector) and the concerns about urban weakness and global uncertainty. The actual outcome will hinge significantly on the strength of the urban economy and Capital expenditure fillip as budgeted and the broader global economic environment.
Important Caveats:
- The review acknowledges inherent uncertainties in the forecast, citing geopolitical factors, global economic slowdowns, and potential inflation pressures.
- The forecast is based on data available as of September 2024 especially some of the good macro-economic indicators like first half sales of Vehicle sales, GST collections, excellent direct tax collections, manageable Current account deficit to GDP ratio etc Unexpected changes in global commodity prices or unforeseen domestic events, could significantly alter the projections and if they remain within a band of normal volatility, the resilience of the economy will be able to take care of it.
- In summary, a cautiously optimistic outlook prevails. While positive factors suggest continued economic growth, several downside risks exist, potentially leading to lower-than-expected growth for FY25. The actual outcome will depend on numerous economic and geopolitical variables that aren't fully predictable but India's momentum is slightly tilted in favour of growth between 6.7% to 7% for the year
No comments:
Post a Comment